Integrating Schools and the Challenge of Building Civil Society: Part 1

I am an American who has lived in Northern Ireland for the past 10 years. I also work as a Policy Officer for the Alliance Party of Northern Ireland, which is a cross-community political party.

I was motivated by two of Tony Gallagher’s original questions: (1) US schools are not integrated by race or economic status; and (2) Is school integration necessary for rebuilding civil society? This posting addresses the first.

Education policy is pretty much the domain of individual states in America, and Paul Frankmann provides a fine description of the situation in Ohio (which is coincidentally where I’m from).

What may be of particular interest to this forum is the nature of the education system in Northern Ireland, where a religiously segregated system has been formal public policy for decades.

With the foundation of the Northern Ireland state, a 1923 law established three classes of schools: Controlled, Maintained, and Voluntary. Controlled means control by the state. Originally this meant that only fully controlled schools got 100% state funding, hence known as “state schools”. Catholic schools are in the Voluntary sector. The effect of the 1923 law was for Voluntary (Catholic) schools to lose all state funding except teachers’ salaries and heating costs.

One should remember that in the Republic of Ireland, primary and secondary education is effectively under the control (to this day) by the Catholic Church.

In Northern Ireland, the Catholic Church complained about the discriminatory funding effects of the 1923 law, and Protestant churches complained that the law was too secular. The law was updated in 1930 to bring 50% funding for Voluntary schools and to allow religious instruction in Controlled (state) schools. State funding to Voluntary (Catholic) schools was increased to 65% in 1947, and 80% in 1968; they are now 100% funded by the state.

In a sense, the 1923 law represents a more familiar American-style separation of church and state. Any attempt to secularise the education system in Northern Ireland would fail, and there is no effort for this. Integrated education will have to compete as just another sector in the NI education system. (This is also the case for the Irish-language education sector.)

Considering the very segmented education system in Northern Ireland (there’s a state-funded elite grammar sector, too), I have found it remarkable that the public (state-funded) school system in America has survived for so long. Indeed, I discovered that the American system originated from the Scottish model. There, the education system was segmented along denominational lines. The response was to establish “communal” schools, whereby everyone in a geographic community would be educated together. It was a radical concept at the time, and its premise is not as universally accepted (esp. in NI as well as England) as it is in the US.

The downside to this community-style education system is that in a free society, people are free to move, and in the modern age of suburbia, inner cities get left out, particularly in the hyper-devolved taxation system in America. *Some* or even *many* US schools may not be integrated on race or economic status, but it is not official public policy, as the religious segregation policy in Northern Ireland is.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s