The irreverent periodical, The Vacuum, published with support from the Arts Council, has a thought-provoking piece on how any contemporary nostalgia for the Troubles in Northern Ireland is premature, mainly because nostalgia evokes something shared (WWII and the Blitz, Communism and particular consumer choices) and something with a defined end (ditto above).
In the case of the Troubles, while the gross violent manifestations of it may be over, what was the shared experience? Something to be nostalgic about?
Colin Graham suggest that it would be better for a collective exercise of kitsch nostalgia (James Young DVDs, Orange Order mugs, RUC jackets), than the alternative of re-running the extreme politics of the past.
I don’t disagree, except that who says we aren’t still running the politics of the past? Politically motivated violence and state abuses may be no more, buy by Graham’s own analysis, me thinks Northern Ireland resembles the status quo ante of Russia, where we’ve stripped the ideology of bullets as persuasion, but not our manners and customs of division.
Yet still, as Colin Graham argues, if we do get nostalgic about the Troubles, then they really must be over.
March 2009 (Issue 42)
Colin Graham (The Vacuum)
Not all nostalgias are equal, but they do all have the necessity ot be inaccessible, either because what they represent will never return (even if it’s recent), or because they are so remote from the present that it is relatively harmless, and ultimately pointless, to imagine what is yearned for being reinstated. The most infamous form of nostalgia in Europe in recent years is ‘Ostalgie’, an East German phenomenon which harks back to the days of the GDR. This is manifested in film (Goodbye, Lenin) and in television programmes fondly recalling the lifestyle of times lived under the GDR. Most interestingly it manifests itself as a physical hunger for the actual tastes of food under the communist regime, so that companies have made a profit recreating the products on the regulated shelves of pre-1989 East Germany.
Ostalgie has been controversial in the reunified |Germany, and it does have its extreme elements, but it is largely contained by its own understandable perversity. This contrasts with Russia where the break with the communist past was never a clean one. Gorbachev brought about the downfall of the Soviet bloc slightly against his will and desires, and did so form within the party. After Yeltsin the party more-or-less got itself back into its previous position, albeit stripped of its old ideological clothes, if not its manners and customs. There is now a resurgent Bolshevik party in Russia, though it’s not seen mas much of a political threat — though being actively nostalgic for Bolshevism does seem more committed than the consumerist nostalgias which are peddled in the West, where we are encouraged to coo about Spangles sweets, or Blur v. Oasis, or strikes.
There is nothing quite so impressive or coherent in Northern Ireland as there is in the former Soviet Bloc, nothing which might yet be called a real Troubles nostalgia. We’re hardly going to want to reconstitute an old political ideology because we still have the same ones we always had; we largely eat the same food (with cappuccino added); and we can feed off British and Irish forms of social nostalgia if we feel the urge. In any case, the period of the Troubles may have sucked most of the nostalgic energy out of Northern Ireland, since there was a form of nostalgia running through the Troubles years, perhaps most strongly in unionism, which tended to look back on the pre-Troubles era as one with a settle social order in which things weren’t so bad. Even in nationalism this understandable desire for a bit of peace could be manifested as a remembrance of rural or urban community and for better ways of living.
We live in nostalgic times though. Most of Northern Irish ‘culture’ has been made nostalgic through tourism or an idea of heritage, which is a handy way of packaging the past in order for it not to be too intrusive in the designs of the present. The Troubles is nearly all that is left for nostalgic commidification. The undercurrents of the process are starting to flow. The British Army didn’t figure large in the pre-Troubles period, but their withdrawal gives some hints of the shoots of nostalgia as they begin to poke through the rubble left over from the Troubles. When the Second Battalion Princess of Wales’s Royal Regiment left Bessbrook for the last time in 2007, Colonel Wayne Harber (as reported by the BBC) cautiously regretted the moment, saying: “The Army doesn’t deal in sentiment but there’s a hint of nostalgia and that thread of continuity and the significance that this is the longest military campaign in the army’s history.” Nostalgia can be very subjective.
Nostalgic forms of history are usually commodified in some way that hides their existence as a produce or sales item. One turn that nostalgia takes, through heritage and into a quiet form of commodity selling is via the route of the hobby. Why, for example, are railways, cars, tractors and ships so frequently the object of (male) nostalgia? Partly because they lead to male friendships in which men don’t have to talk to each other about anything important. If there is to be a Troubles nostalgia (and the industry which creates and markets it) it will come surely through a mixture of geekiness, local history, and displaced macho-militarism, the kind of vicarious thrills which are lived out by grown men in England dressing as Cavaliers and Roundheads and sham fighting each other.
We have, of course, a model for this at Scarva. We also have one at the Ulster-American Folk Park, where you can watch Confederates take on the Union forces daily in the summer. It would be possible for the same ‘actors’ to swap clothes and periods — the trouble is, again, while there is no point in betting on the outcome at Scarva or Omagh (King Billy and the Union always seem to win), a more contemporary version, apart from being utterly tasteless, would never get off the ground, not least because we wouldn’t have a clue how to stage a winner … or a beginning or an end. We’d probably end up with two parallel re-enactments.
Nostalgia tends to produce and rely on kitsch: some material object that becomes over-invested with historical significance and is then sold on the basis of that useless value for its uniqueness, collectability or authenticity, the idea being that somewhere within the object is the essence of History and how it really was. In this sense a Troubles nostalgia would have no problems producing its own kitsch, since many of the accouterments of the Troubles had a touch of kitsch about them anyway (what could be more kitsch than the Orange Order or the AOH?). The process has started. On eBay, unsurprisingly, there is a plethora of RUC ‘memorabilia’. You can get an RUC Masonic tie pin for £2.00, or a ‘genuine’ RUC cap for £9.99 (fake versions are much cheaper). At the time of writing there is a very tempting ‘OBSOLETE HISTORICAL ITEM’, which is ‘Collectible!’. It’s an original RUC jacket (42″), priced at £0.99 with just three days to go. The urge to save it from absolute obsolescence is almost overwhelming.
And if I had bought it there would have been one profitable way to turn it into a living form of Troubles nostalgia. There is, apparently, a phenomenon, in South Armagh in particular, of strippers (male and female) ‘performing’ in RUC uniforms. And then performing without them. Henry McDonald, writing in the Observer in 2003, quotes one female stripper: “She said she was still surprised at the popularity of the uniform: ‘In the hardest republican and loyalist areas they just want me as the RUC woman. The boys ask me to handcuff them and caution them. It’s as if they miss the thrill of it all.’”
According to your inclinations, this may or may not be less tasteful than the idea of a re-enactment. It does seem to provide some form of catharsis, though, and that’s perhaps the ultimate point of nostalgia. Books of old photographs of pre-Troubles tractors in Tyrone, or watching James Young DVDs may have an element of Ulster nostalgia to them, but none of them directly allows for the release of the tension left over from the Troubles. We’re hardly capable of it yet. It would be immoral and in bad taste. That’s why it’s happening on eBay, in pubs and in the attics of ‘collectors’. But what if the same urges are in the psychic attics of most of the population? Wouldn’t it be better if they got dusted off as kitsch nostalgia? The alternative might be a re-run of those desires as real politics. If we ever do get a full-blown Troubles nostalgia industry then we’ll know that it’s all over.